Madeline Miller’s “Song of Achilles” is an adaptation of the Iliad and the Trojan War, from the perspective of Patroclus. Published in 2011, this novel attempts to apply current concepts of gender studies and queer relationships to the days of Ancient Greece.
Readers familiar with the myths that are the backbone of this book may find themselves disappointed. Patroclus especially seems to be inaccurately portrayed as an awkward healer instead of the extremely powerful warrior capable of fighting demigods, as we see more of in the “Iliad.”
The relationship between Achilles is toxic and heteronormative as well. Achilles’ obsession with glory frequently dominates any genuine emotional reciprocity for Patroclus, who is completely consumed by Achilles and would do anything for him. Instead of enriching the myth with complexity, the narrative simplifies both characters, flattening their motivations and diminishing the tragedy that made their story enduring.
That being said, Madeline Miller has a unique, enchanting writing style, and the novel is easy to read. It has a heartfelt ending, and Miller’s choice of telling the story from Patroclus’ point of view makes it intriguing.
Rating: 6/10